What is balance billing? Know the facts.

Balance billing has long been a source of concern, especially in discussions about out-of-network care and reference-based pricing (RBP) plans. But many perceptions of balance billing were shaped by a healthcare environment that looks very different today.

Quick facts about balance billing

Common belief
What the facts show

Balance billing is common. 

Many of the surprise billing situations that once generated the greatest concern are now protected by federal law, making balance billing less common than it was in the past.

Every balance bill is valid. 

Receiving a balance bill does not automatically mean the amount is owed. Federal and state protections may apply, and billing errors can occur.

Balance billing is a bigger concern with reference-based pricing (RBP) plans. 

Balance billing occurs with all types of health plans. An RBP plan does not make balance billing more likely. For Imagine360 members, fewer than 3% of claims result in a balance bill, a number that is in line with healthcare industry standards.

Patients are on their own if they receive a balance bill. 

Patients have legal protections and dispute resolution options. In addition, many RBP plans provide enhanced member advocacy and support to help members address billing concerns, rather than requiring them to navigate the process on their own.

How balance billing has changed

Before the federal No Surprises Act (NSA) went into effect in 2022, concerns about surprise medical bills were widespread. According to a 2020 survey, 65% of insured adults were at least somewhat worried about unexpected medical bills.  

At the time, 18% of emergency room visits and 16% of in-network hospital stays resulted in at least one out-of-network charge that could lead to a surprise bill, according to KFF.  

Today, many of those scenarios are no longer permitted under federal law. As a result, the balance billing environment looks very different than it did just a few years ago. Research suggests the law has successfully reduced many of the surprise billing situations that once left patients caught in the middle of payment disputes.

How balance billing works

Balance billing occurs when a healthcare provider bills a patient for the difference between the provider’s charges and the amount paid or allowed by the health plan. For example: 

  • Provider charges: $1,000 
  • Health plan pays: $700 
  • Remaining balance: $300


If the provider seeks payment of the remaining $300 from the patient, that’s called balance billing. 

Balance billing is most commonly associated with care received from out-of-network providers.

Balance billing vs. surprise billing

These terms are often used interchangeably, but they’re not exactly the same. 

Balance billing occurs when a provider bills a patient for charges beyond what the health plan pays. 

Surprise billing is a type of balance billing that occurs when a patient unknowingly receives care from an out-of-network provider.

How the No Surprises Act changed surprise billing

The No Surprises Act established federal protections for many of the situations that historically led to surprise bills, including: 
  • Emergency services Patients generally cannot be charged more than their in-network cost-sharing amount for emergency care, even if the provider is out-of-network.  
  • Certain non-emergency services provided at in-network facilities Patients are protected when receiving certain services from out-of-network providers at in-network hospitals, outpatient departments, and ambulatory surgery centers.  
  • Air ambulance services The law also includes protections for many air ambulance situations.

While these protections have reduced many common surprise billing scenarios, balance billing can still occur in certain situations, such as when a patient knowingly chooses to receive care from an out-of-network provider.
 

Imagine360’s experience with balance billing

Looking at claims data from 2015 to 2025, Imagine360 has seen balance bill rates decline from 14.4% of claims to 3%. Today, fewer than 3% of Imagine360 claims result in a balance bill, a rate consistent with industry averages.

Questions to ask when evaluating a health plan

While federal protections have reduced many of the billing situations that once fueled concerns, billing questions can still arise. That’s why it’s important to evaluate not only a health plan’s cost and benefits, but also how it supports members when billing questions arise.

When assessing a health plan partner, consider:

  • Does the plan provide dedicated member advocacy and billing support?
  • Who is responsible for resolving billing concerns: the member, employer, or health plan?
  • What resources are available to help employees understand bills and EOBs?


Dedicated advocacy and support can help reduce employee frustration, improve the member experience, and provide greater confidence when navigating healthcare costs.

Infographic overview of self-funded health plans

Frequently asked questions

What is balance billing?

Balance billing occurs when a healthcare provider bills a patient for charges beyond what the health plan pays or allows.

No. Deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance are forms of cost sharing that are built into a health plan’s design. Balance billing occurs when a provider bills a patient for charges beyond what the health plan pays or allows. While both result in out-of-pocket costs, they are not the same thing.

Yes. While the No Surprises Act reduced many of the surprise billing situations that historically generated concern, balance billing can still occur in certain circumstances, such as care received from an out-of-network provider by choice, certain ground ambulance services, and other situations not covered by federal protections.

In some situations, yes. Balance billing may occur when a patient knowingly receives care from an out-of-network provider. However, federal and state laws restrict or prohibit balance billing in many common surprise billing situations, including most emergency services and certain services provided by out-of-network providers at in-network facilities.

Common exceptions to the No Surprises Act protections include ground ambulance services, care received at an out-of-network facility by choice, certain situations where a patient knowingly consents to out-of-network care, and elective services provided by out-of-network providers when applicable notice and consent requirements are met. 

The No Surprises Act applies to most self-funded employer health plans. Before the law was enacted, state surprise billing protections often did not extend to self-funded plans. The No Surprises Act established federal protections that now include most self-funded employer health plans.

No. Balance billing can occur with any type of health plan and is not more common simply because a plan uses RBP. In fact, some RBP plans provide dedicated member advocacy and support to help members address billing concerns should balance billing occur. 

Receiving a balance bill does not automatically mean the amount is owed. The claim may still be processing, additional review may be needed, or federal and state protections may apply. 

Members should review the bill, compare it to their Explanation of Benefits (EOB), and contact their health plan to discuss the charge. Some health plans may help investigate billing concerns, communicate with providers, or assist with resolution. 

Your health plan can do
better. We promise.